Cal's Pals Paddle for Preemies
Join us for Cal’s Pals Paddle for Preemies, a 120-mile paddle from Cape May to Sandy Hook, NJ, on July 19–20, 2025. This inspiring event raises funds to support families with children in the NICU and PICU. Be part of a meaningful journey along the Jersey Shore and help make a difference.
Welcome to The Bagel Shop of Cape May
Experience the taste of authentic NY-style bagels right here in Cape May. Our family-owned shop brings you five generations of bagel baking tradition. We’re excited to bring our family’s love of baking to Cape May. We use fresh, local, organic ingredients and we offer a wide variety of bagels, homemade cream cheeses and salads, sandwiches, coffees, and a full market of items to go.
Local Favorites
-
Bagel With Your Favorite Topping
Select from our delicious bagel varieties and top with our homemade cream cheese spreads, nut and seed butters.
-
Smoked Nova Special
Your choice of bagel with smoked Nova salmon, tomato, red onion, capers, and your choice of cream cheese.
-
Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich
Your choice of bagel with two large organic eggs, melted America cheese, and your choice of meat (bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, or pork roll)
-
Homemade Deli Salads
Choose from chicken, tuna, or egg salad, freshly prepared in-house.
-
Cold Brew Coffee
Smooth and refreshing, brewed cold for a rich flavor.
-
See the Full Menu & Order Online
Enjoy our Bagels Delivered right to your Home
Can’t make it to the shop? We offer next day home delivery so you can enjoy our fresh bagels and cold brew coffee from the comfort of your home.
Five Generations of Bagel Baking Tradition
Our family has been crafting authentic NY-style bagels for over five generations. We bring traditional methods to Cape May, boiling our bagels first and then baking them on burlap for that perfect texture and flavor. Being family-owned, we take pride in every bagel we make, ensuring quality and authenticity in every bite.
What Our Customers Are Saying
